Finding an intelligent alien civilization would easily rank among the most profound discoveries in human history.

So far, though, there are no signs of communicating extraterrestrial life, no messages from the stars suggesting that humans are not alone in the universe. Maybe, some scientists argue, it’s time for us to take a more active role in the interstellar conversation. Instead of simply eavesdropping on the cosmos as we’ve done for the past half-century, perhaps Earth should begin transmitting messages to the stars – big, blazing telegrams meant to prompt an extraterrestrial reply.

But actively sending signals into the cosmos is more than a slightly controversial idea. Recently, a statement posted online asserted that messaging extraterrestrial intelligence (METI) carries “unknown and potentially enormous implications and consequences.” Signed by a number of well-known scientists – and people such as Elon Musk – the missive asks that a vigorous international debate take place before any new messages are sent.

That debate erupted at the American Association for the Advancement of Science’s annual meeting, where several contentious exchanges broke out as scientists gathered to discuss the pros and cons of interstellar messaging.

“We should launch active SETI as an ongoing complement to our traditional passive SETI projects,” said Doug Vakoch, director of interstellar message composition at the SETI Institute. “It’s a matter of diversifying our search strategies.”

But undertaking a targeted interstellar messaging campaign without considering the potential consequences is foolish, argued astrophysicist and science fiction author David Brin. The seeming lone voice of dissent among the convened panelists, Brin noted that attracting the attention of an unknown advanced civilization could bring potentially disastrous results. And, he said, it’s impossible to predict whether aliens are going to play nice or be real jerks.

“This is the only really important scientific field without any subject matter,” Brin said. “It’s an area in which opinion rules, and everyone has a very fierce opinion.”

Right now, there are no official messages waiting in Earth’s interstellar outbox. But Vakoch and others are floating the suggestion of using the Arecibo Observatory’s mega-powerful transmitter to send a series of messages in the down time between the observatory’s other studies. It wouldn’t cost much at all, and it would join the ongoing campaigns to listen for alien transmissions. While the question of what to include in those messages is obviously important, it’s taking a backseat to the issue of whether those messages should be sent at all.

“Active SETI, I gotta admit, is a controversial topic,” Vakoch remarked.

Despite the ongoing controversy, it wouldn’t be the first time interstellar messages have been beamed into space. A handful of transmissions have already left Earth’s shores and set sail across the cosmos. Perhaps the best known of these messages was sent from Arecibo in 1974, as part of a ceremony marking the completion of an upgrade to the giant radio telescope. Composed by astronomer Frank Drake, the message has been hurtling through space at the speed of light, destined to intersect in 25,000 years with a globular star cluster in the constellation Hercules.

And then there’s all the stuff that’s wafting into space without any such effort from Earthlings. These murmurs from Earth include the high frequency chirping of military radars, TV and radio transmissions, and the interplanetary radar used to study numerous asteroids in the solar system. Recently, technologies like cell phones and cable TV have turned Earth into a slightly quieter pale blue dot, but for many decades, our intra-planetary communications were easily leaking into space.

True, those signals are much harder to detect than a blast of directed radio waves from Arecibo, but SETI Institute senior astronomer Seth Shostak argued that any civilization advanced enough to show up and annihilate the planet is also advanced enough to detect those murmurs. In fact, he notes, our technology isn’t too far from being able to do the same. “We are within one or two centuries of being able to find the equivalent of ourselves,” he said.

In other words, it’s too late to shut up and hide.

But Brin isn’t buying it. And he bristles at the suggestion that he and his colleagues are simply worried about “slathering Cardassian invaders.” Instead, he implores, wouldn’t it make more sense to have a conversation about the potential ramifications of METI before we begin shouting into the void?

It does seem like a conversation is beginning to take place.

At the meeting, several panelists attempted to cut through the supposition and opinion by drawing analogies between METI and other controversies. Astrobiologist David Grinspoon noted the obvious link between METI and NASA’s Planetary Protection Office, created to prevent biological contaminants from being passed between Earth and other solar system bodies. “That’s a discussion that’s been had internationally, and I think that’s quite relevant here,” Grinspoon said. He also noted that fears of extraterrestrial intelligences with nefarious intent are not dissimilar to concerns about the motivations of artificial intelligence.

“That certainly presents an existential threat. It may be tiny — people have different opinions on it – but how are we dealing with that?” Grinspoon asked, noting that no one has shut down artificial intelligence research.

Later, federal judge David Tatel offered the rather salient observation that this debate is not unlike the controversy swirling around dual-use research on harmful pathogens, where learning more about nasty viruses could be used to engineer an especially potent bioweapon. And noted similarities with the current debate over geoengineering and how to combat climate change.

“Both of these have similarities with active SETI,” he said. “Both could produce great benefits or have catastrophic consequences.”



Follow Alien UFO Sightings: On Facebook 👽👊👍


Arne Sørensen · May 20, 2015 at 7:58 pm

Very interesting, when we will have a public contact with aliens is a matter of time i think, we have to wait and see ?☺?☺

Jordan Brock · May 18, 2015 at 1:47 am

the strange part is on friday watching ancient aliens i herd one of the shows from the people that talk on the show it was a woman guests recite what i was talking about 6 months ago to a few other people on a scientific facebook page word for word i know that is my own scientific conclusion because i came up with it a few years ago. it was on the Subject of Each Galaxy having only one Civilization and one only and that is the way Nature intended it to be and since there are a supposed Billions of Galaxies like the Milky way has earth and what ever Belongs to earth in it. its funny that i didn’t talk about the other part in a whole that wasn’t talked about. as a civilization grows and reaches out they fill the Galaxy and if there was only one Civilization in each Galaxy the universe would still be teaming with Life even so Vastly apart there would be trillions upon trillions of beings to do exploring and sending singles But as big and Massive as our Galaxy is and even though there are trillions of Life forms out there most as a type 3 and 4 civilization no matter how advanced anyone is its still a lot of Galactic Real estate to cover. that is the Key Word in Next Season of ancient Aliens lets see if that shows up in one of the shows. as i know the universe. The Human Body and all the Billions of People on earth have a Vast Data Base of knowledge in there brains un taped Lets put it this way we know everything that there is to know about everything our thoughts and dreams and imaginations are the power and a interlocking Database to every picture and every though and what ever we think is really out there. but throughout the Millennia we lost the Password or the Galactic Flash drive and have no idea how to use it or it was some how taken away or once was part of our DNA or what they call today Junk DNA. if you ever herd the story that one persons Dreams are someone else’s reality Like the Universal Market place that Hundreds or even thousands of Civilizations are part of they can buy anything trade anything eat anything if it Exists in the universe it will be sold there and maybe thats what all the grays are doing here they might be the Middle men or Middle Beings that scour the universe for things like cow parts and human Blood and Plants and air and water gold and Jewels or even trade your old Ship in for a Newer one. its very easy to Explain something away and wash your hands of it but when you start asking the questions and thinking about it and answering the questions yourself. in terms of the Universe We just Might Be the Flat Landers and might start poking our heads out of our own Bubble and really start to see whats out there

Russell Smith · May 17, 2015 at 6:05 pm

They’re already here, my theory is they are letting us become technologically addicted…and we’ll wake up one morning and find the plug has become pulled…….so learn the basics of #survival

Joe Pavlic · May 17, 2015 at 5:31 pm

Careful what you wish for…

ookiee · May 17, 2015 at 4:49 pm

wouldn’t it be better if we tidied up a bit first?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts


Ancient Mayan Artefacts: or Another Hoax?

Since late 2011, a story has been circulating around various websites of a cache of carved stones and clay tablets that were allegedly discovered in an old Mayan temple. These artefacts bare images of classic, Read more…


SHOCK CLAIM: Baltic Sea Anomaly contains metals ‘nature CANNOT produce’

THE mysterious Baltic Sea Anomaly contains metals that nature “could not produce” by themselves it has been claimed and the revelation has sent UFO hunters into a frenzy. The odd-shaped object has fascinated mystery buffs Read more…

Alien Contact

The Fermi Paradox Is Not Fermi’s, and It Is Not a Paradox

Despite what you’ll often read, the Nobel prizewinning nuclear physicist never suggested that aliens don’t exist. Two big ideas often come up in discussions about the search for extraterrestrial intelligence, or SETI. One is the Drake Equation, Read more…